Monday, February 4, 2019

How much do the “Little Women” Actually Change?


Little Women by Louisa May Alcott is an enlightening story to read. It follows the lives of four girls that learn to grow up and live happily, despite their individual faults. Ultimately, they learn to place love and happiness over materialistic wealth. One might note how Meg, Jo, Amy, and Beth all overcome their flaws and live happily as women. I would argue that the “little women” do not change drastically in their lives, rather they learn to be happy and accept themselves for who they are.
Amy began her life as a “selfish pig” (9). She claimed that the greatest trial of her life was her nose, which was quite comical. Throughout the novel, Amy was very materialistic. She even says that she would marry a man simply for his wealth. She grows and changes her opinion on these things, and she learns to love others more than herself. She proves this by marrying Laurie, not for his wealth but for his character. However, even when she does this, she still was “taking conjugal strolls over velvet carpets” (467).        
Jo’s greatest flaw is her “quick temper, sharp tongue, and restless spirit” (38). She struggles throughout the novel to grow up and behave like a woman. It is not until she marries Professor Bhaer and creates a school for boys that she is truly happy. By being surrounded by children and a loving husband, she is able to be herself. Unlike the other girls, Mr. Bhaer and her enjoyed walks “along muddy roads and sodden fields” (467). This is a part of her character that she never changes, even though she grows to be a loving mother and wife.
Meg improves upon her character flaw, which is her fondness of luxury. However, the improvement does not come without conflicts. She married a poor man, recognizing the trials she would face in the future. When she said to John that she was “tired of being poor,” it led to one of the married couple’s first arguments (283). Besides this, she always had a motherly attitude about herself that she carried with her for the rest of her life. She is successful in raising her family and loves her husband dearly.
In the end, each of the March children keeps core pieces of their personalities with them for their entire lives. While nothing substantial can be said for Beth because of her short life, she persisted throughout the novel as a “peacemaker,” and she continued to be this after her death. All the while, Meg, Jo, and Amy grow to be happy women. In the end of the novel, the three sisters reflect on their old “castles in the air” (489). While each of the sisters acknowledges that their dreams were changed, they realize they are happy in their new lives. Their goals were achieved not by considerably altering who they were as individuals, but by using their unique characteristics to be good women.                                                                                                                                 

4 comments:

  1. I think that you make a great point about how the girls don’t change much but instead become happy with who they are. The whole “Pilgrim’s Progress” theme in the book does seem to be pushing them to change who they are, but it really encourages improvement. Personal improvement does not necessarily mean that who you are is wrong. It merely means that you should minimize the bad and capitalize on the good.

    In a way this makes me think about how both in Ragged Dick and Little Women, people are encouraged to suppress their impulses. For many people, their impulses and indulgences are the negative parts of their identity. For instance, with Meg when she buys the massive amount of silk when she couldn’t afford it (281), her impulse to buy nice things stems from her envy and jealousy of Sallie’s nice things. The book does not condemn Meg or any of the girls for wanting nice things; it scolds them for being jealous and acting upon the wicked desires. Meg learns that pining after extravagance will get her nowhere and she already has a delightful home right in front of her. Once she learns this, she focuses more on her home life and improving the household to the best of her ability. After about year of married life, they manage to create a home that Sallie becomes envious of. A happy home that “the poorest may possess, and the richest cannot buy” (399).

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with a lot of what you have said here; the girls themselves do not evolve into entirely new people but yet do change. This change is brought about by the everyday lives of the girls. There are situations, scenarios, and problems that teach the girls what to do and how to act. Alcott is keen on the girls living their own lives and not conforming to society, yet at times they do. Marmee lets the girls make those mistakes to then learn from then and grow.

    These mistakes can be seen throughout the book whether it is Amy throwing a party and trying to impress the more well off girls in her art group or the girls not doing chores for a week which eventually comes back to bite them. One event that I think shows the evolution of the girls and how they are still very much flawed halfway through the novel is when Beth falls ill with Scarlet Fever. "How dark the days seemed now, how sad and lonely the house, and how heavy were the hearts of the sisters..." (183). Beth is being so selfless that she herself comes down with the illness when her sisters Meg and Jo could have very well went over there because they had already had the disease. Alcott is showing us that there are flaws in the journey, and although they are evolving they still remain what makes them uniquely themselves. Meg still has a materialistic side to her, but works her hardest to be a good housewife against the wishes of Jo. Jo writes and takes care of the family in some of its darkest times, yet she still tears up months of hard work because she felt it wasn't what she should be doing. The girls all move throughout their lives and learn from their mistakes, but in the end the March sisters still can be identified as who they were in the beginning.

    ReplyDelete

  3. I think you bring up a very important idea with your argument that the March sisters learn from their own personal experiences throughout the novel as a way to accept who they are. While the March sisters definitely mature and evolve as people over the course of the novel, they learn to embrace their character traits as strengths.

    Like we discussed in class, I think the maturation of the March sisters’ characters is best embodied through the obstacles they endure over the course of the novel. The lessons they learn come from personal experience, which I think is important for them to gain the most from each trial. For example, while Meg does her best to be a good wife like she always envisioned, she forgets her “duty to [her] husband in [her] love for [her] children” (391). Through this realization, she learns to make more time for her husband, resulting in a breakthrough that allows them to share responsibility in raising their children and spend more time together at home. Additionally, previously in the novel, Amy hosts a garden party (which Marmee knows will fail) in order to teach her a lesson about who she is and what her social status is (264). Amy still desires wealth, but learns to change for herself and not for other people.

    Overall, the trials of each of the March sisters is reflective of their personalities, and while they mature as characters, they learn to embrace their personalities and use their character traits to their advantage.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think you bring up a very important idea with your argument that the March sisters learn from their own personal experiences throughout the novel as a way to accept who they are. While the March sisters definitely mature and evolve as people over the course of the novel, they learn to embrace their character traits as strengths.

    Like we discussed in class, I think the maturation of the March sisters’ characters is best embodied through the obstacles they endure over the course of the novel. The lessons they learn come from personal experience, which I think is important for them to gain the most from each trial. For example, while Meg does her best to be a good wife like she always envisioned, she forgets her “duty to [her] husband in [her] love for [her] children” (391). Through this realization, she learns to make more time for her husband, resulting in a breakthrough that allows them to share responsibility in raising their children and spend more time together at home. Additionally, previously in the novel, Amy hosts a garden party (which Marmee knows will fail) in order to teach her a lesson about who she is and what her social status is (264). Amy still desires wealth, but learns to change for herself and not for other people.

    Overall, the trials of each of the March sisters is reflective of their personalities, and while they mature as characters, they learn to embrace their personalities and use their character traits to their advantage.

    ReplyDelete