Tuesday, March 5, 2019



Time is the True Indicator of Someone's Character, Not First Impressions



It takes about 3 seconds to evaluate someone. In a matter of a glance, you can form an initial opinion about the kind of person someone is based on appearance, body language, dress, and mannerisms. But is that first impression one that sticks and is true to someone’s actual character and personality? In most cases no. In Pride and Prejudice, the example of the first impression between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth proves to be misleading. Initially Mr. Darcy is prejudiced against people who are in a lower class and have less income than himself. Because Elizabeth falls into the lower class, Mr. Darcy’s attitude towards her proves to be unwelcoming and he doesn’t see her as a potential mate. At the ball, Mr. Darcy turns down Mr. Bingley’s offer to dance with Elizabeth because she is “tolerable, but not handsome enough to tempt [him]”(Austen). Concurrently, Elizabeth notices Mr. Darcy’s comments about her, and develops a misjudgment of her own about Mr. Darcy, seeing him as stuck-up and rude. Her pride in reading others, causes Elizabeth to develop the wrong first impression of Mr. Darcy as well as hold a grudge. This grudge is seen in the Youtube series, The Bennet Diaries, where Elizabeth talks for more than three videos describing her encounter and disgust in Mr. Darcy, even titling one of her videos about him as “Snobby Mr. Douchey”(Bennet Diaries). In the beginning, Darcy is not attracted to Elizabeth, and Elizabeth is offended by his pride and arrogance. However, this first judgment of each other shows to be incorrect when Mr. Darcy notices his attraction to Elizabeth and proposes to her later on in the novel and Elizabeth becomes more exposed to Mr. Darcy’s good character. Another example of wrongful first impressions is the introduction of Mr. Wickham. Initially Mr. Wickham is perceived as a handsome and good character man because “he had all the best parts of beauty, a fine countenance, a good figure, and a pleasing address”(Austen). However later in the novel, Mr. Wickman proves the other characters in the novel and reader’s initial impression of him to be wrong when we are introduced to his debt and gambling problems, as well as motives to entice naive women such as Lydia.
However, the novel does prove that not all first impressions are wrongfully made and can reveal people’s true character as well. In Mr. Bingley’s case, Jane and the reader’s first impression of him was that he was “good-humored”, “lively”, and an overall good man(Austen). Because of this initial perspective, Jane is first attracted to him at the beginning of the book when she met him. Bingley proves to be the man he appears to be.
Because of these initial interactions and impressions between the characters, Pride and Prejudice’s original title was “First Impressions”. The novel proves to the reader that first impressions are important, however people shouldn’t a great amount of energy into the first encounter because with time your true character will show. Especially, with Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy’s case, time is the true indicator of someone’s character, not the first impression.
It takes about 3 seconds to evaluate someone. In a matter of a glance, you can form an initial opinion about the kind of person someone is based on appearance, body language, dress, and mannerisms. But is that first impression one that sticks and is true to someone’s actual character and personality? In most cases no. In Pride and Prejudice, the example of the first impression between Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth proves to be misleading. Initially Mr. Darcy is prejudiced against people who are in a lower class and have less income than himself. Because Elizabeth falls into the lower class, Mr. Darcy’s attitude towards her proves to be unwelcoming and he doesn’t see her as a potential mate. At the ball, Mr. Darcy turns down Mr. Bingley’s offer to dance with Elizabeth because she is “tolerable, but not handsome enough to tempt [him]”(Austen). Concurrently, Elizabeth notices Mr. Darcy’s comments about her, and develops a misjudgment of her own about Mr. Darcy, seeing him as stuck-up and rude. Her pride in reading others, causes Elizabeth to develop the wrong first impression of Mr. Darcy as well as hold a grudge. This grudge is seen in the Youtube series, The Bennet Diaries, where Elizabeth talks for more than three videos describing her encounter and disgust in Mr. Darcy, even titling one of her videos about him as “Snobby Mr. Douchey”(Bennet Diaries). In the beginning, Darcy is not attracted to Elizabeth, and Elizabeth is offended by his pride and arrogance. However, this first judgment of each other shows to be incorrect when Mr. Darcy notices his attraction to Elizabeth and proposes to her later on in the novel and Elizabeth becomes more exposed to Mr. Darcy’s good character. Another example of wrongful first impressions is the introduction of Mr. Wickham. Initially Mr. Wickham is perceived as a handsome and good character man because “he had all the best parts of beauty, a fine countenance, a good figure, and a pleasing address”(Austen). However later in the novel, Mr. Wickman proves the other characters in the novel and reader’s initial impression of him to be wrong when we are introduced to his debt and gambling problems, as well as motives to entice naive women such as Lydia.
However, the novel does prove that not all first impressions are wrongfully made and can reveal people’s true character. In Mr. Bingley’s case, Jane and the reader’s first impression of him was that he was “good-humored”, “lively”, and an overall good man(Austen). Because of this initial perspective, Jane is attracted to him at the beginning of the book when she met him. Bingley proves to be the man he appears to be.
Because of these initial interactions and impressions between the characters, Pride and Prejudice’s original title was “First Impressions”. The novel proves to the reader that first impressions are important, however people shouldn’t put too much emphasis into the first encounter because with time your true character will show. Especially, with Elizabeth and Mr. Darcy’s case, time is the true indicator of someone’s character, not the first impression.

4 comments:

  1. I agree that the novel puts a lot of emphasis on first impressions. It is easy to look at Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth’s relationship and see that Austen’s work shows us that first impressions are not always correct, and that you should get to know someone better before you judge them. However, I think Jane and Bingley’s relationship is more difficult. It is true that their first impressions of each other are correct, they are both kind and caring people. Their personalities are very similar to one another, and they make a connection immediately when they dance together at a ball, shortly after Bigley first arrives in town.

    In the novel, Charlotte Lucas says that Jane should be more open about her feeling with Bingley or he might not think she cares for him (Austen, 23). Her warning proves true when eventually Bingley is talked out of his affections for Jane by those around him. If Jane had showed more affection, would Bigley still have left? Or does this have more to do with Bigley’s character than Janes? So what is Austen trying to say here? Maybe you cannot be so stubborn that you judge people incorrectly based on your limited interactions with them, but you also cannot be so easily swayed that you can be talked out of your true feelings either. Perhaps she is trying to show that we need to have some sort of balance between the two.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I completely agree with you on the belief that first impressions after often times wrong. It usually takes numerous interactions and several meetings with someone in order to gain a true understanding of their character and personality. Our first impressions can also be drastically misled if the person is first met in a situation or environment that is uncomfortable to them.

    Elizabeth first sees Mr. Darcy at a ball and has no direct interaction with him. Mr. Darcy does not particularly enjoy balls and dancing which is understood by his response to Mr. Bingley telling him he should dance, “I certainly shall not. You know how I detest it, unless I am particularly acquainted with my partner” (13). Being in an uncomfortable environment can cause people to become irritated and unpleasant, just as it does Mr. Darcy.

    Additionally, it isn’t completely fair to Mr. Darcy that Elizabeth bases her impression of him off of the conversation she overhears between him and Mr. Bingley. While Mr. Darcy is rather rude in regard to what he says about Elizabeth, “She is tolerable; but not handsome enough to tempt me; and I am in no humour at present to give consequence to young ladies who are slighted by other men” (13), he says this to Mr. Bingley in what he believes to be private. I don’t believe that Mr. Darcy would say this if he knew that Elizabeth was able to hear him, especially since he does turn out being a caring gentleman. Elizabeth’s first impression of Mr. Darcy is rather biased since he doesn’t directly interact with her and she overhears a conversation he has with his best friend.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with the underlying theme of your blog, as first impressions are put on a pedestal in this novel. As we were told, the initial title of the book was actually "First Impressions," which shows how much significance is placed on it during the book. As Darcy was asking Elizabeth to dance, she responded sharply with "I entreat you not to suppose that I moved this way in order to beg for a partner" (27). Elizabeth turned away a perfectly nice gesture just because she had already made predetermined thoughts about Darcy. Darcy yet had been mostly a perfect gentleman for the time being.

    This trend can be seen throughout the novel as characters jump to conclusions, which can put them in precarious situations. The novel does a remarkable job of bringing to light everyday situations that we can still relate to today. Jumping to these sorts of conclusions can be very damaging in real life and the book. Not allowing a person to properly introduce themselves can create dangerous ambiguity. Thus, we may create false narratives for people instead of letting them create their own. It is true that we never know what someone is going through, so to put words in their mouth would be wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete